Prof. George C Schatz
Editor-in-Chief
The Journal of Physical Chemistry,                          Dr. Zhong-Heng YU
Department of Chemistry                                        Institute of Chemistry
Northwestern University                                         Chinese Academy of Sciences
2145 Sheridan Road, Evanston,                              Beijing 100080
IL602083113                                                         P.R.China  

                                                                              Oct. 1, 2008
                                                                              yuzh@iccas.ac.cn
                                                   

Dear Editor and Prof. Schatz:

     According to the 30-Sep-2008 E-mail from the office of Prof. and Senior Editor Michael Duncan, we would submit the following manuscript (reply paper)， “Response to "Comment on "Restricted Geometry Optimization: A Different Way to Estimate Stabilization Energies for Aromatic Molecules of Various Types"""，to J. phys. Chem. A. Two authors are presented in this manuscript. Dr. Zhong-Heng Yu is the corresponding author. Dr. Peng Bao's contact information is the same as the corresponding author.

    Whether pi-electron delocalization is stabilization or not have been a subject of controversy for several decades.  Therefore, we hope that the comment and our response can be published in J. Phys. Chem. A.  Due to conflict of interest, I don't hope the following researchers are the reviewers: (i) P. v. R. Schleyer; (ii) xxxxxxx. (iii) xxxxxx.

     We would like to open the source codes of our calculation program to the researchers who are interested in our program. We have to get authorization from Prof. Granovsky first, though the revised version of PC-Gamess program is being developed in our research group.

Thank you very much and Sincerely Yours

 

Zhong-Heng YU
Professor and Ph. D. of
Physical Organic Chemistry

 

 

 

 

转载本文请联系原作者获取授权，同时请注明本文来自虞忠衡科学网博客。
链接地址：https://m.sciencenet.cn/blog-94786-207842.html

上一篇：Our JPCA Paper: "Restricted Geometry Optimization: A Different Way To Estimate S
下一篇：Peer-Reviewer's Comment on Manuscript: "Restricted Geometry Optimization: A Diff