关于Publish or Perish以及Publish and Perish的博文汇总 最近由于井冈山大学论文告假事件引起了连锁反应，一直存在的问题再次炒热。。。 汇总一下有关文章链接，一为方便自己备忘，另外也可方便到访的朋友。 不断更新中。。。 0、Nature文章（Publish or perish in China）链接 http://www.nature.com/news/2010/100112/full/463142a.html 1、王鸿飞的发表就是灭亡（ http://www.sciencenet.cn/m/user_content.aspx?id=286891 ） 2、引用到任胜利的Publish or perish vs. Publish and perish（ http://www.sciencenet.cn/m/user_content.aspx?id=18830 ） 3、刘立的publish or perish机制及其变种：有感于Nature文章 ( http://blog.sciencenet.cn/m/user_content.aspx?id=286925 )
春雷一声震天响，井冈山回荡久长；赝品七十登雅堂，虎年开篇名声扬。 2009牛年刚过，2010虎年伊始，最受我国大陆地区作者青睐的《晶体学报E辑》（Acta Crystallographica Section E Structure Reports Online, 简称ACS-E），也是2007年我国入选SCI数据库论文来源最多的期刊，在2010年第一期的开篇却发表了苏格兰阿伯丁大学William T. A. Harrison，新西兰奥塔哥大学Jim Simpson以及奥地利维也纳理工大学Matthias Weil三位联合撰写的编者按，披露了井冈山大学H. Zhong和T. Liu二位涉及70篇论文造假之事，同期也刊登了二位以及论文合作者的撤稿声明。这种国内开花国外红的多篇造假事件的背后，值得我们反思的不仅仅是作者的诚信问题，更为重要的是我们的学术生态环境、科研成果评价体系。在名与利的诱惑之下，科学研究的初衷被严重扭曲了。《晶体学报E辑》有51%的作者来自CHINA，其他国家很少(详见： doi:10.1107/S1600536808042979 ； http://journals.iucr.org/e/contents/backissues.html )。表1统计结果除了特别注明来源于SCI或者ACS-E网站之外，均来自CA数据库。 表 1 《晶体学报 E 辑》论文来源统计结果 Year 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 影响因子 IF(SCI) 0.453 0.491 0.581 0.567 0.508 0.367 0.484 发表论文 / 篇 (ACS-E) 802 925 1305 1809 2887 3991 5181 3556 4162 中国论文 / 篇 60 129 327 728 1406 2085 2636SCI 1811SCI 1968(SCI) 论文来源单位 299 362 401 496 642 846 1066 985 1346(SCI) 中国论文来源单位 18 47 65 116 199 313 416 430 555(SCI) Authors from countries P ercentages China 51% India 6% USA 5% Germany 4% Malaysia 4% Iran 3% Pakistan 2% Other countries smaller 为什么近年来的论文造假事件频频出现？为什么总是有人敢于铤而走险？亡羊补牢的教训留给人们的启示究竟是什么？希望一声春雷能够带来中国大地学术生态环境新景象。 详细信息请参考： William T. A. Harrison a； Jim Simpson b and Matthias Weil c a Department of Chemistry, University of Aberdeen, Aberdeen, AB24 3UE, Scotland; b Department of Chemistry, University of Otago, PO Box 56, Dunedin, New Zealand, and c Institute of Chemical Technologies and Analytics, Division of Structural Chemistry, Vienna University of Technology, Getreidemarkt 9/164-SC, Austria http://journals.iucr.org/e/issues/2010/01/00/me0406/me0406.pdf Retraction of articles by H. Zhong et al. H. Zhong, a* S.-H. Duan, a Y.-P. Hong, a M.-L. Li, a Y.-Q. Liu, a C.-J. Luo, a Q.-Y. Luo, a S.-Z. Xiao, a H.-L. Xie, a Y.-P. Xu, a X.-M. Yang, b,a X.-R. Zeng a and Q. Y. Zhong c a College of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Provincial Key Laboratory of Coordination Chemistry, Jinggangshan University, Jian 343009, Peoples Republic of China, b Institute of Applied Materials, Jiangxi University of Finance and Economics, Nanchang 330032, Peoples Republic of China, and c Jian Training School, Jian 343000, Peoples Republic of China http://journals.iucr.org/e/issues/2010/01/00/me0404/me0404.pdf Retraction of articles by T. Liu et al. T. Liu, a* Y.-X. Wang, b Z.-W. Wang, a Z.-P. Xie a,c and J. Y. Zhu d a College of Engineering, Jinggangshan University, Jian 343009, Peoples Republic of China, b College of Mathematics and Physics, Jinggangshan University, Jian 343009, Peoples Republic of China, c Department of Chemistry, Jiangxi University of Science and Technology, Ganzhou 341000, Peoples Republic of China, and d Department of Information Engineering, Jiangxi University of Science and Technology, Nanchang 330013, Peoples Republic of China http://journals.iucr.org/e/issues/2010/01/00/me0405/me0405.pdf
Here is the link to 井冈山大学2009年校园十大新闻: http://news.jgsu.edu.cn/info/news/20091224311.html Updates (Dec. 26th, 2009): Clearly, I had a reason to post this link. I searched for this link, because I wanted to see how the school reacted to the incident of 70 papers being forced to withdraw. Clearly, the school decided to play the monkey who sees no evil, hears no evil, and ... There are lessons to be learned. Maybe the ScienceNet can host a debate about Science in China after the 70-paper-gate? Updates (Dec. 27th, 2009): 井冈山大学校领导回应学校70篇论文被撤事件 thanks to 李炳照的博客 .
标签: 井冈山大学
