里瑟琦智库分享 http://blog.sciencenet.cn/u/idmresearch

博文

基于维基百科的大学影响力排名

已有 3873 次阅读 2016-2-11 18:06 |系统分类:观点评述|关键词:学者| 高等教育, background, 大学排名, 影响力, 英语国家

哪所大学最具有全球影响力?这一问题逐渐地主导着公众、政府和资助机构对高等教育发展道路抉择。因为文化、历史、地理等因素都以各种难以量化的方式来影响排名,解决这个问题的难点在于很难形成一个考虑所有客观因素的大学排名,比如英语作为世界上最通行的语言,其对英语国家以及英语国家大学的影响是难以准确衡量的;加之不同的研究机构对教学和科研的重要性有不同的看法,如何权衡这些因素也成为了提升大学排名可信度的一个重要方面。

法国Franche-Comte大学的Jose Lages教授及其团队利用Google引擎的网页排名算法,对24种不同语言版本的维基百科的内容进行了数理统计分析,生成了基于维基百科的世界大学排名(WRUR)。虽然世界上现存287种语言,但这24种语言的使用者涵盖了世界人口总数的59%,相关文章覆盖了维基百科文章总数的68%

与传统的大学排名相比,维基百科大学排名更倾向于具有较大影响力的历史悠久的大学。比如柏林洪堡大学在维基百科上排名第11位,但其并未出现在传统大学排名的前100名中,而该大学却已培养出29位诺贝尔奖获得者。同时,基于维基百科的大学排行榜存在较明显的国家多样性,美国排名第一,德国排名第二,英国紧随其后,排名第三。日本和印度的大学也更为突出,还包括了埃及爱资哈尔大学等非洲大学。总的来说,美国大学在新排行榜中不太突出,占总数的38%。新排行榜对非英语系国家均进行了较为客观的分析,包容了不同文化视角下对世界大学的看法。附表是以PageRank算法生成的基于维基百科的世界大学排名(WPRWU)TOP200

当然,基于维基百科的大学影响力排名不可能完全取代传统的大学排名,但它为分析高等教育与研究的现状提供了一种新方法新思路,应该以积极的方式引起这方面的广泛探讨

附表:基于维基百科的世界大学排名Top200

Rank

Theta_PR

Na

University

CC

1

2272

24

University of Cambridge

UK

2

2247

24

University of Oxford

UK

3

2112

22

Harvard University

US

4

2025

23

Columbia University

US

5

1887

23

Princeton University

US

6

1869

21

Massachusetts Institute of Technology

US

7

1783

22

University of Chicago

US

8

1765

21

Stanford University

US

9

1716

20

Yale University

US

10

1557

19

University of California, Berkeley

US

11

1531

21

Humboldt University of Berlin

DE

12

1481

22

Cornell University

US

13

1351

20

University of Pennsylvania

US

14

1285

20

University of London

UK

15

1224

19

Uppsala University

SE

16

1209

20

University of Edinburgh

UK

17

1195

20

Heidelberg University

DE

18

1193

18

University of California, Los Angeles

US

19

1171

20

New York University

US

20

1131

18

University of Michigan

US

21

1119

19

Johns Hopkins University

US

22

1113

19

University of Vienna

AT

23

1099

18

University of Gottingen

DE

24

1030

16

London School of Economics

UK

25

990

19

Moscow State University

RU

26

974

19

University of Bologna

IT

27

948

18

Leipzig University

DE

28

928

15

California Institute of Technology

US

29

911

18

Ludwig Maximilian University of Munich

DE

30

764

15

University of Southern California

US

31

752

17

University of Tokyo

JP

32

743

15

Leiden University

NL

33

707

11

Lund University

SE

34

680

13

Charles University in Prague

CZ

35

668

12

University College London

UK

36

577

11

University of Copenhagen

DK

37

576

11

école Normale Supérieure

FR

38

570

14

University of Manchester

UK

39

556

13

école Polytechnique

FR

40

538

14

University of Bonn

DE

41

523

11

University of Texas at Austin

US

42

519

15

Duke University

US

43

507

15

Carnegie Mellon University

US

44

505

9

Al-Azhar University

EG

45

490

10

University of Helsinki

FI

46

487

15

University of Virginia

US

47

483

12

Hebrew University of Jerusalem

IL

48

470

12

University of Toronto

CA

49

460

9

King's College London

UK

50

450

9

Imperial College London

UK

51

447

11

University of Illinois at Urbana–Champaign

US

52

429

10

Sapienza University of Rome

IT

53

428

8

ETH Zurich

CH

54

426

12

University of Zurich

CH

55

389

12

University of Washington

US

56

377

12

University of Minnesota

US

57

373

12

Georgetown University

US

58

373

10

University of Wisconsin–Madison

US

59

361

10

McGill University

CA

60

351

9

University of Glasgow

UK

61

346

8

University of Oslo

NO

62

346

7

Peking  University

CN

63

344

6

Michigan State University

US

64

340

13

Brown University

US

65

338

8

University of Tübingen

DE

66

332

8

Jagiellonian University

PL

67

327

8

Saint Petersburg State University

RU

68

324

8

Free University of Berlin

DE

69

324

5

Kyoto University

JP

70

317

9

University of Padua

IT

71

314

7

Karolinska Institutet

SE

72

301

5

Waseda University

JP

73

300

5

University of Florida

US

74

298

6

University of Geneva

CH

75

295

6

Ohio State University

US

76

273

7

University of Jena

DE

77

269

5

Keio University

JP

78

262

9

University of Arizona

US

79

261

6

University of Maryland, College Park

US

80

260

6

Stockholm University

SE

81

248

5

Trinity College, Dublin

IE

82

247

7

Boston University

US

83

245

6

University of Strasbourg

FR

84

239

6

University of Tartu

EE

85

236

7

Rutgers University

US

86

234

4

Institut Polytechnique des Sciences Avancées

FR

87

232

6

University of Warsaw

PL

88

228

6

Utrecht University

NL

89

227

6

University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill

US

90

224

4

Rockefeller University

US

91

217

7

Martin Luther University of  Halle-Wittenberg

DE

92

211

5

Tsinghua  University

CN

93

209

6

University of St Andrews

UK

94

208

5

University of Amsterdam

NL

95

204

9

Northwestern University

US

96

204

6

University of Notre Dame

US

97

189

4

Technical University of Berlin

DE

98

189

3

University of Coimbra

PT

99

187

6

Indiana University

US

100

187

3

University of Wrocław

PL

101

185

5

University of Hamburg

DE

102

183

4

University of Cologne

DE

103

182

7

Purdue University

US

104

182

4

University of Marburg

DE

105

179

3

Seoul National University

KR

106

178

4

Cairo University

EG

107

177

4

Dartmouth College

US

108

175

2

Technion – Israel Institute of Technology

IL

109

170

4

University of Graz

AT

110

167

5

Pennsylvania State University

US

111

165

4

University of Freiburg

DE

112

165

4

University of Kiel

DE

113

165

4

University of Belgrade

RS

114

164

3

University of Sydney

AU

115

162

3

Meiji University

JP

116

162

2

Linköping University

SE

117

161

2

Université libre de Bruxelles

BE

118

159

6

University of Basel

CH

119

158

4

University of Gothenburg

SE

120

157

3

University of Greifswald

DE

121

156

5

Versailles Saint-Quentin-en-Yvelines  University

FR

122

154

4

Brigham Young University

US

123

151

6

Washington University in St. Louis

US

124

151

3

Linnaeus University

SE

125

149

4

University of Iowa

US

126

148

3

Nanjing  University

CN

127

146

3

Ghent University

BE

128

145

2

Lviv University

UA

129

144

3

American University of Beirut

LB

130

143

6

University of Pittsburgh

US

131

143

3

George Washington University

US

132

143

3

University of Liverpool

UK

133

142

2

University of Groningen

NL

134

139

3

Aarhus University

DK

135

138

3

University of Florence

IT

136

137

2

University of Liège

BE

137

136

3

Technische Universität München

DE

138

136

2

National Autonomous University of Mexico

MX

139

135

5

University of Hawaii

US

140

134

3

Nihon University

JP

141

133

3

University of Paris-Sud

FR

142

131

2

Paris West University Nanterre La Défense

FR

143

130

5

University of California, San Diego

US

144

129

4

University of Melbourne

AU

145

129

2

University of Naples Federico II

IT

146

128

2

Istanbul Technical University

TR

147

128

2

Kansas State University

US

148

125

3

University of Lausanne

CH

149

124

4

University of British Columbia

CA

150

124

3

Goethe University Frankfurt

DE

151

124

2

Fudan University

CN

152

123

3

University of Pavia

IT

153

123

2

University of Erlangen-Nuremberg

DE

154

123

2

University of Tennessee

US

155

122

2

Istanbul University

TR

156

119

2

Yıldız Technical University

TR

157

118

2

Osaka University

JP

158

117

2

Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv

UA

159

116

5

University of Salamanca

ES

160

116

3

Shanghai  Jiao Tong University

CN

161

116

2

Alexandria University

EG

162

114

2

University of Münster

DE

163

114

2

Chuo University

JP

164

114

2

Radboud University Nijmegen

NL

165

114

2

Middle East Technical University

TR

166

112

4

National University of Singapore

SG

167

112

2

Dresden University of Technology

DE

168

111

3

Tel Aviv University

IL

169

111

2

Takushoku University

JP

170

110

4

University of Birmingham

UK

171

110

2

Marmara University

TR

172

110

2

University of Malaya

MY

173

106

4

Syracuse University

US

174

105

2

Shiraz University

IR

175

103

2

National and Kapodistrian University of  Athens

GR

176

103

2

VU University Amsterdam

NL

177

103

2

Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore

IT

178

102

2

Damascus University

SY

179

102

2

Umeå University

SE

180

102

2

Paris-Sorbonne University

FR

181

100

4

University of Latvia

LV

182

100

3

Complutense University of Madrid

ES

183

100

2

Weizmann Institute of Science

IL

184

100

1

Eötvös Loránd University

HU

185

100

1

Chulalongkorn University

TH

186

100

1

University of Tehran

IR

187

100

1

University of the West Indies

JM

188

99

2

Maastricht University

NL

189

99

1

Budapest University of Technology and  Economics

HU

190

99

1

Korea University

KR

191

99

1

Aristotle University of Thessaloniki

GR

192

99

1

Thammasat University

TH

193

99

1

Nalanda University

IN

194

98

2

University of Barcelona

ES

195

98

1

University of Szeged

HU

196

98

1

University of São Paulo

BR

197

98

1

Yonsei University

KR

198

98

1

Adam Mickiewicz University in Poznań

PL

199

98

1

Kasetsart University

TH

200

98

1

Ankara University

TR

说明:Theta_PR=Theta PageRank scoreNa=Number of appearances in the 24 WikipediaeditionsCC= countrycode

 

(卞月妍整理编译。Sources:Wikipedia Ranking of World Universities, Wikipedia-Mining Algorithm Reveals World’sMost Influential Universities




https://m.sciencenet.cn/blog-2903646-955615.html

上一篇:两份不同的高被引科学家榜单背后有何玄机?
下一篇:MIT和Caltech科学家探测到引力波,你只需要知道这么多

3 史晓雷 张端鸿 decipherer

该博文允许注册用户评论 请点击登录 评论 (0 个评论)

数据加载中...
扫一扫,分享此博文

Archiver|手机版|科学网 ( 京ICP备07017567号-12 )

GMT+8, 2024-5-23 14:53

Powered by ScienceNet.cn

Copyright © 2007- 中国科学报社

返回顶部